Unbiased camcorder reviews, advice, and prices
  • Sorry, the guide you were looking for is no longer available. Here's a list of our current guides and editorial roundups.
Note: this camcorder was first sold in Mar 2006. There may be newer versions available.
Panasonic VDR-D200
Panasonic VDR-D200
F
HQ Grade: F
A is outstanding and exceptional, rated in the top 10% of camcorders.
B means they are good, with some standout features.
C means they are mediocre, and probably more trouble than they are worth.
D & F mean they are absolutely awful or old. Avoid at all costs.
  • 3 out of 5
"No transfer movies to my Laptop"
  • 3 out of 5
"trouble with finalising"
See rating based on 16 user reviews
Submit your own Panasonic VDR-D200 review!
This camcorder is ranked
Ask

Have a question about the VDR-D200?
Enter it here: (You can enter more details in the next step)

Back to List
Question Answered!
Shelly Petrman (spete33) 2 pts

Sony DVD or Sony Hard Drive Camcorder?

I am trying to decide between a Sony dvd or a Sony Hard Drive Camcorder, then model. We use it to tape family events and occassionaly the kids need to use for a school project and make a video with some editing. Could anyone give me some ideas as to what is best? I am upgrading from a Sony DCR-TRV103.
Report Abuse Did you find this question helpful or not helpful?

This question is also associated with Panasonic VDR-D230, Canon DC230 and Panasonic VDR-D100.

Answers This question has been answered!
Piero Foto (ifotomedia) 7096 pts
June 2, 2007 1:01 AM
2 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
Hey, Shelly.
A hard drive camcorder is a far better choice than DVD camcorders. I strongly recommend to stay away from DVD disc camcorders if you are planning to do any downloading, editing, and making DVD copies.
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
Piero Foto (ifotomedia) 7096 pts
June 2, 2007 9:07 AM
10 people rated this answer helpful, 1 people rated this answer not helpful
 
Here are your best consumer cam picks in each media type.

DVD cams:
Panasonic VDR 200
Canon DC40
Canon DC50
Canon DC230
Sony DCR DVD505

Hard drive cam:
Panasonic HDC-SD1
Sony Handycam HDR-SR1
Sony Handycam HDR-UX1
Sony Handycam HDR-HC3
JVC Everio GZ-MG77

MiniDV:
Canon HV20
Panasonic GS320
Panasonic GS500
Sony HC46
Sony HC96

They all produce very nice video picture quality from low to high end, but its going to depend on what you do with your video footage once its been captured, that's what will determine which cam to buy. Keep-in-mind, newer technology does not always mean better, but many times it just offers more choices for consumers.

- If you are just looking for a point-and-shoot camcorder and play direct to TV, then just flip a coin to select anyone.
- If you are planning to interact with computers, then that eliminates DVD disc cams.
- If you want to tranfer your video to make DVD copies, then any miniDV or the higher model hard drive cams will be best.
- If you are a demanding consumer/videographer that needs a cam with easy transfer/downloading, editing, making best DVDs/VCDs, and maintaining best final picture results, the miniDV cam would the best undisputed choice.

MiniDV is the prefered choice by professionals. The miniDV camcorders I have listed, are the only miniDV camcorders I recommend that do not record in an MPEG format or any other compressed video format to produce best results.

Hard drive camcorders also produce a nice quality, and I would recommend them for a second choice since they record with an MPEG compressed video format, but what ever you buy, stay away from DVD cams.

Happy Shopping!
Best Answer
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
Shelly Petrman (spete33) 2 pts
June 4, 2007 9:38 AM
1 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
Thanks so much for your advice - after spending some time on the internet reading past posts and other sites, it appears that the majority suggest staying away from DVD recorders.
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
elalar 0 pts
June 14, 2007 9:20 PM
0 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
We may or may not edit our videos on our computer so I'm curious as to why DVD format is not recommended.
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
Piero Foto (ifotomedia) 7096 pts
June 14, 2007 9:56 PM
0 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
elalar.
DVD camcorders are not for everyone, but here are some threads to some DVD camcorder reasons why to buy or not buy.

http://www.digitalcamera-hq.com/camcorders/panasonic-vdrd200_question.html?qid=3880

http://www.digitalcamera-hq.com/camcorders/panasonic-vdr-d230_question.html?qid=13557



Here are some threads to common DVD camcorder issues and problems:

http://www.digitalcamera-hq.com/camcorders/canon-dc230_question.html?qid=13411

http://www.digitalcamera-hq.com/camcorders/panasonic-vdrd200_question.html?qid=12953

http://www.digitalcamera-hq.com/camcorders/panasonic-vdrd100_product-questions.html

http://www.digitalcamera-hq.com/camcorders/panasonic-vdrd200_product-questions.html



Surf around this site and you will see more of why you would not want a DVD cam.

Bottom Line:
If you are still interested in buying a DVD cam after reading some of these threads, then a DVD camcorder is good for you. Buy it!

Happy Shopping!
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
elalar 0 pts
June 15, 2007 11:43 PM
0 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
Piero, thanks for the links. Actually, we ended up getting a mini dv today.
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
Piero Foto (ifotomedia) 7096 pts
June 16, 2007 12:13 AM
0 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
That's great elalar., Happy movie making!
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?

This Question is Answered. If you have further information you may add it here.

Need to add formatting or links? Use BBCode.
Spell-check
Helpful Guides
Most Popular
Price Range
Resolution
Camcorder Brand
Media Format
Hands-On Reviews
Camcorder Type
Our Other Sites

Close
Loading