Unbiased digital camera reviews, advice, and prices
Canon Powershot SX1 IS
Canon Powershot SX1 IS
B+
HQ Grade: B+
A is outstanding and exceptional, rated in the top 10% of digital cameras.
B means they are good, with some standout features.
C means they are mediocre, and probably more trouble than they are worth.
D & F mean they are absolutely awful or old. Avoid at all costs.
  • 5 out of 5
"Good Camera in a small package"
  • 5 out of 5
"Raw Format"
See rating based on 73 user reviews
Submit your own Canon SX1 IS review!
This camera is ranked
Ask

Have a question about the SX1 IS?
Enter it here: (You can enter more details in the next step)

Back to List
Question Answered!
M. (mkwapisz) 3 pts
November 26, 2008 7:22 AM

Powershot SX1 IS vs. Powershot Pro1

Please help me understand the difference...
SX1 has a smaller sensor than Pro1, although it is type of CMOS and not CCD.
Would SX1 still generate better pictures (especially night pictures or indoor, with the tripod)? I checked SX110 and the night pictures are really poor quality comparing to Pro1.
I would really appreciate the answer as I currently have Pro1 and want to 'upgrade' to SX1 .... or Nikon D90 (which also can record HD movie clips)
Report Abuse Did you find this question helpful or not helpful?
Answers This question has been answered!
by James DeRuvo (byjamesderuvo) 58446 pts
November 26, 2008 6:16 PM
0 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
Well let me ask you this, M, why do you want to upgrade? Is it for more MP? Don't fall for the myth that more megapixels make for better pictures. In fact, it can be quite the opposite.
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
M. (mkwapisz) 3 pts
December 2, 2008 6:44 AM
0 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
Hi James,

I do realise that megapixels are not the true representation of picture quality.
But you didn't really answer my question... so I will try to answer your question.
My Powershot Pro1 is a great camera. Having it for almost five years I start to look for 'more' in the compact camera.
Right know the main reason for wanting a new camera is that Pro1 produced high noise in higher ISO settings... yes I know it is only a compact camera, but I hope that with the new technology this can be better (maybe in SX1)....
In addition, I do love taking short movie clips. Pro1 is very limited in clips time (30sec in higher quality), lacks ability to zoom while filming and.... (the biggest) lacks ability to adjust light when panning from well lighted are to dark area.
So can I ask again to let me understand the new sensor? Would SX1 give me what I miss in Pro1??

Cheers
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
by James DeRuvo (byjamesderuvo) 58446 pts
December 2, 2008 12:58 PM
3 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
Well, the main reason why point and shoot cameras produce noise at higher ISOs is due to stuffing small CCD chips with more and more megapixels. This makes chips less sensitive to light, not more. Hense, more noise at higher ISOs. So, in your search, you need to look for a camera that has increased chip size to accommodate more mega pixels.

Along with the SX1, two cameras that do this are the Canon G9 and G10. Both have larger chips than the standard fair, and IIRC, the G10 has the new DIGIC IV. Both help to accommodate the 14MP that's crammed onto it. The irony is, you don't really see a difference over the G9 (at 12MP) in sizes up to about 11x14. After that, you start to see the difference. And since 99.9% of pictures won't even come near that, one has to wonder why the P&S world is so obsessed with the "more mp is better myth."

So I think that, yes, the SX1 would be a good camera for your needs. Especially with video, where recording time on the SX1 is only limited by the available size of your flash memory card.
Best Answer
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?
D80 10 pts
January 8, 2009 3:48 PM
3 people rated this answer helpful, 0 people rated this answer not helpful
 
Pro 1 is DIGIC 2 and SX1 is DIGIC 4. Like grandpa compare to grandson.
Did you realized the difference between Intel 286 processor and 486?

Pro 1 is 7X and SX1 is 20X. I paid about $300 for the Pro1 1.5X zoom extender to make it X10.5. Now, it is free and better.
Pro 1 is CCD and SX1 is CMOS.
SX1 can do HD, Pro 1's video? I even don't want to talk about it.
Watch 5D II's sample HD video on dpreview.com, they are as good as my Canon HF10 HD.
It beats Dishnetwork HD (compressed). Only, out of air (OOA) HD can beat Canon HF10.
Report Abuse Did you find this answer helpful or not helpful?

This Question is Answered. If you have further information you may add it here.

Need to add formatting or links? Use BBCode.
Spell-check
Start Here!
Most Popular
  1. Panasonic FZ35
  2. Canon SD1200 IS
  3. Canon 500D
  4. Canon A1000 IS
  5. Canon SX20 IS
  6. Panasonic FS15
  7. Samsung SL30
  8. Canon 50D
  9. Nikon D90
  10. Canon SX120
Camera Brand
Price Range
Camera Type
Camera Line
Megapixels
Hands-On Reviews
Latest Cameras
Top Searches
Our Other Sites

Close
Loading